Casey Rutherford
Milton & Alpharetta Listing Agent

We started working with Casey about 9 months ago to begin the search in Milton for a home with more space. We weren’t in a hurry to find a new home because we loved our current home in Brookhaven so much. We have very specific tastes we know what we like and what we don’t and what we’re willing to invest in. Casey took time to really understand what we were looking for - she never made us feel pressure to move into a house we weren’t sure about- she always had our best interest at heart. We even walked away from a house we had gone under contract for, but Casey didn’t miss a beat - she simply said “It’s not the one and we’ll keep looking”. She event...

We’ve retyped this review multiple times because it’s incredibly difficult to put into words just how much of an impact Casey made on our home-buying process. There were so many factors working against us finding our dream home (our budget, a seller’s market, a sought-after neighborhood, etc.), but Casey somehow made it possible. Her industry knowledge, vast network, and “get it done” approach gave us so much confidence along the way. We always felt seen and prioritized, and we saw her go above and beyond for us time and time again. If you’re looking for a realtor who will truly go to bat for your family, you’ll be in great hands with Casey.

If you are thinking about selling your home in the Atlanta metro area your first call should be to Casey Rutherford. We had seven offers on our house in just a few hours after putting it on the market and ended up getting $75,000 over the asking price. We even had a water leak two weeks before closing and Casey was able to get all of our floors replaced which made a stressful situation for us very manageable. Even with this huge problem with our house, we were able to close with the original closing date and the new homeowner was happy to get new floors. Casey was professional, easy to work with, and honest. We 100% recommend her.