Meet Casey
Casey Rutherford is a Milton resident, mother of three, and top-producing real estate agent serving Milton, Alpharetta, and North Atlanta’s luxury market. For Casey, real estate is not just about property. It is about people, timing, and the life that unfolds inside a home.
Before building her real estate career, Casey spent nearly a decade in corporate consulting, where she developed a disciplined, analytical approach to strategy and negotiation. Today, that background translates into data-driven pricing, thoughtful positioning, and confident representation for the clients she serves.
Living in Milton with her husband Barry and their three children gives Casey a daily, firsthand understanding of the community she represents. From schools and neighborhoods to local businesses and lifestyle amenities, she knows what makes each pocket of Milton unique — and how to communicate that value to buyers.
Casey believes that preparation is everything. She guides her sellers through intentional pre-market strategy, refined presentation, and elevated marketing designed to maximize value. She approaches every listing with the same care and diligence she would demand for her own family’s investment.
Consistently recognized as a top-producing agent and named the #1 individual agent in the Ansley Real Estate North Atlanta office in 2024 and 2025, Casey pairs boutique-level service with the global reach of Ansley Real Estate | Christie’s International Real Estate.
When she is not working with clients, you will likely find her at a swim meet, golf tournament, or dance recital — fully immersed in the same community she proudly serves.
For Casey, home is deeply personal. And representing yours is a responsibility she takes seriously.
