Meet Casey
Casey Rutherford is a luxury real estate advisor with Peachtree Town & Country. She serves buyers and sellers in Milton, Alpharetta, and North Atlanta. In 2025 she finished in the top ten in sales volume with the Atlanta REALTORS® Association, out of 14,000+ agents across our great metro area. Her business is built on sharp pricing, intentional preparation, and representation that protects her clients’ equity.
For Casey, real estate isn’t just about property. It’s about people, timing, and the life that unfolds inside a home.
Before real estate, Casey spent nearly a decade in corporate consulting. That work gave her a disciplined, analytical approach to strategy and negotiation, and it shows up in every engagement: data-driven pricing, thoughtful market positioning, and steady, confident negotiation.
Casey believes preparation is everything. She guides sellers through a deliberate pre-market strategy, refined presentation, and elevated marketing designed to maximize value. She approaches every listing with the same care she’d demand for her own family’s investment. Buyers get the same rigor: clear guidance on value, neighborhoods, and how to compete for the right home.
That approach is why she joined Peachtree Town & Country, a luxury boutique firm built on a hospitality-first standard of service. It’s a natural fit for an advisor who pairs top-producer results with a high-touch, personal experience.
Casey lives in Milton with her husband, Barry, and their three children, so she knows the community she represents firsthand. From schools and neighborhoods to local businesses and lifestyle amenities, she knows what makes each pocket of Milton distinct and how to communicate that value to buyers.
When she’s not with clients, you’ll likely find her at a swim meet, golf tournament, or dance recital. She’s fully part of the community she proudly serves.
For Casey, home is deeply personal. Representing yours is a responsibility she takes seriously.
